The holidays are the perfect time to indulge. Since I’ve lived in Williamsburg for many years, I know exactly where to find the best sweets and treats. Williamsburg has so many hidden gems that offer up delicious holiday desserts, not to mention exceptional sweets year-round.
Here’s a collection of locally owned Williamsburg bakeries and sweet shops where you’ll find delectable holiday treats and everyday indulgences.
Aromas Coffeehouse Bakeshop & Cafe
In Merchants Square, Aromas Coffeehouse Bakeshop & Cafe has the best coffee and biscotti in town, plus warm, inviting vibes. During the holidays, Aromas offers holiday cakes that are not only gorgeous with fun and festive decorations, but also large enough to share with family and friends.
They also regularly stock pies, cakes, cookies, and more, including crave-worthy gluten-free and vegan cookies. In the spring, swing by their stand at the local farmers market. Pro tip: they have the BEST basil lemonade!
Wythe Candy & Gourmet Shop
Also in Merchants Square, Wythe Candy & Gourmet Shop is one of our family’s favorite local shops. Not only are they the perfect spot for finding unique stocking stuffers, but they also offer pre-packaged treats you can only find in Williamsburg (this candy shop is unique to the area). The family-friendly atmosphere is so welcoming.
Some top picks include the caramel apples, chocolate-dipped strawberries, and truffles. Plus, you can’t go wrong with their pre-packaged hot chocolates – they’re a fun way to try new flavors throughout the season.
Chowning's Cider Stand
With its historic setting and old-time menu, this is truly a great place to get the full Colonial Williamsburg experience! Chowning's Cider Stand is best known for their ginger and queen cakes (the ginger cakes are one of my daughter’s must-haves). You also can’t pass up a warm cup of cider here, especially during the holiday season. Their friendly and interactive environment is a perfect way to treat your sweet tooth while you’re exploring Colonial Williamsburg with loved ones.
Extraordinary Cupcakes
Extraordinary Cupcakes strikes the perfect balance of sweetness without being over-the-top. They use high-quality ingredients like King Arthur flour, pure Madagascar vanilla, and imported chocolate to create the perfect cupcakes.
Find these truly extraordinary cupcakes inside Illy Caffé in Merchants Square.
Emily's Donuts and Cafe
Just a few minutes’ drive from the Colonial Williamsburg Historic Area, Emily's Donuts and Cafe is a go-to for big, fluffy doughnuts with amazing texture and flavor. This family-owned cafe is one of my first recommendations for anyone coming to Williamsburg – you can’t beat their delicious doughnuts and amazing customer service.
Around the holidays, expect doughnuts decked out in festive seasonal colors and designs. They’re a fun treat for a casual morning or a decadent breakfast on-the-go.
Carrot Tree Kitchens
With two locations in the Historic Triangle, Carrot Tree Kitchens Williamsburg and Carrot Tree Kitchens Yorktown have been serving up fresh-baked goods for decades. While the food menus and desserts vary between locations, the highlights include scratch-made, beautifully decorated cakes, cupcakes, pies, tarts, cookies, scones, and more. Ask about their vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, including gluten-free chocolate cakes.
More Holiday Experiences for a Sweet Getaway
Beyond sweets, you’ll find plenty more to savor when it comes to Williamsburg’s flourishing food and drink scene. Discover top restaurants for memorable holiday dining or fine dining, and check out local craft breweries, wineries, or distilleries to get in the spirit.
Plus, explore the full lineup of holiday events and experiences to make your seasonal getaway magical from start to finish.
Follow Tabitha via Instagram and on her site at Tabitha Sewer.
